Zero-Hour Employment Contracts

Zero hours contracts have, for many businesses, largely replaced the concept of the casual worker.

By employing workers without any guarantee of set hours, or indeed any hours, businesses can tailor their staffing levels according to the ebb and flow of demand. This is particularly useful for industries and sectors which have seasonal fluctuations in demand or are affected by other factors which influence the volumes of their transactions. When used legitimately, i.e. to meet business needs, and responsibly i.e. to ensure that workers do have security of employment and certainty of remuneration, these contracts are certainly a benefit to businesses. However, it is the case that many large businesses have not given adequate thought to the welfare of their employees. The controversy arose recently when it became clear that a large number of Sports Direct employees are on zero hours contracts. This is not unusual for retail businesses and there are a number of other clothing retailers that employ their employees in a similar manner. The use of these contracts has a significant implication for workplace relations.

Whilst full-time permanent staff enjoy regular and foreseeable income, the ability to rely on statutory annual leave, sickness benefits and pension contributions, employees on zero hours contracts suffer in all these regards. The unions allege that the use of zero hours contracts compounds the other changes in employment law which have clearly been to the detriment of employees. They say, with some justification, the marked and sudden power shift away from employees to employers has skewed the working relationship which many believe had been developing well in the late 80’s and throughout the 90’s. It is said that employers and employees shared the same goals, i.e success of the business so that the owners of the business and the employees could all benefit in terms of income, certainty of remuneration and continuity of employment.

As of July 29th 2013, employees have lost their rights to bring unfair dismissal claims in the first two years of employment and an employer can dismiss an employee without giving them a reason for dismissal and without following a mandatory procedure. Unions have accused the Government of enabling employers to exploit employees. The division between employers and employees has lead to the perception that employees and employers have different goals and an employee had no compelling reason to work hard for the benefit primarily of the employer. If employees feel exploited, powerless, and vulnerable, it is clear that employers are less likely to be able to secure their loyalty, and hard work. It is argued that employment is more likely to be regarded as just a job, not a career.
We now know that amongst the largest employers, Marks & Spencer, Tesco’s and Asda have all shunned the use of zero hours contracts. Other very large organisations use them sparingly if at all. There are other businesses however, which are entirely dependent on zero hours contracts. Whether or not there is a match between the employees’ needs and those of the employer, the flexibility afforded by zero hours contracts is such that they can make the difference between profitability and unviability.

There are a great many options for employers looking to engage workers. Zero hours contracts are not a panacea for tackling staffing levels and coping with demand. Neither is it the case that creating a workforce of self-employed people will shield any organisation from being regarded as an employer. Courts routinely find that self-employed people are actually employees and there are punitive remedies for those employers who have not paid holiday pay, maternity pay, or sickness benefits. Employers seeking to avoid tax and national insurance contributions may end up with a nasty shock at some stage. For this reason, it is worth seeking expert advice in relation to their workforces. It is advisable to choose Solicitors who are experts in business law and employment law in particular. Solicitors are regulated and are accountable. Increasingly, solicitors engage HR specialists to work alongside their employment lawyers and employers are able to tap into best practice relatively cheaply and with professionals who keep abreast with the frequently changing legal landscape with whom they can enjoy a long-standing business relationship.

© Stephens Scown LLP 2013 – 2014

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *